He Cheated And Wants Me Back – What Now? What Should I Do?

By: Katie Lersch: I often hear from wives who are suddenly faced with this heartbreaking dilemma: their husband cheated, caused tremendous pain, and now—sometimes after weeks or months of uncertainty—he suddenly says he wants to come back.

On the surface, this can sound like good news. Part of you may feel validated that he realizes what a mistake he made. But another part of you may still feel deeply hurt, angry, and unsure if you could ever trust him again.

One woman shared it this way:

“When I first found out about the affair, I was devastated, but my instinct was to try to save my marriage. At the time, though, my husband said he wasn’t sure what he wanted. I had no choice but to start moving forward on my own. Now, just as I’m beginning to accept my new life, he suddenly says he wants me back. I do still love him. But how do I get past what he did? What if I can’t?”

This is such a common situation. And if you are in it, I want to say this: still loving a man who cheated on you does not make you weak. It doesn’t mean you can’t stand on your own. It simply means you are human, and your marriage mattered deeply to you. But none of that means you have to rush into taking him back—or even know right away if you want to.

You Don’t Have To Decide Today: Many wives feel pressured to give an immediate answer when their husband says he wants to come home. But here’s the truth: you don’t have to.

Rushed decisions often backfire. Sometimes women are so relieved at the thought of getting him “back” that they let him move in too quickly, only to realize later that the anger and doubt are still there. Other times, women push him away completely because the fear of being hurt again feels overwhelming.

Both reactions come from raw emotion. But you don’t have to live in extremes. You absolutely have the right to say: “I need time. I need to see real change. I’m not ready to decide today.”

If your husband is truly sincere about wanting you and the marriage, he should respect that.

Doing The Work Before You Reconcile: Here’s what often holds wives back: the fear that he’ll cheat again, or that he’s only coming back because things didn’t work out elsewhere. And those fears are very real. They don’t vanish just because he moves back in.

This is why real work has to happen before reconciliation. If nothing changes, it makes sense to believe nothing will be different. But if you both address the underlying issues—his choices, the state of the marriage, and even your own healing—then there really is a path forward.

This work can be painful. It means looking closely at what went wrong. Some of those issues may not have been about you at all but about his personal struggles. Still, if you address them together, you can gain a deeper understanding of one another. That kind of honesty is what makes it possible to rebuild trust. And sometimes, surprisingly, it creates a stronger marriage than before.

I can’t tell you whether you should take your husband back. That’s a decision only you can make, and only when you’re ready. But here’s what I can tell you:

  • You don’t have to decide today.

  • You don’t have to ignore your doubts.

  • And you don’t have to settle for less than a faithful, honest, and fully repaired marriage.

I’ll admit, I once thought I could never take my own husband back after he cheated. The pain felt too overwhelming. But after time, healing, and a lot of hard work, we did find our way back. And honestly, my marriage is stronger now than it ever was. I would not have believed that a few years ago – but here I am.

If you’d like to read more about the specific steps I took to rebuild after my husband’s affair, I share a very personal story on my blog at http://surviving-the-affair.com.

Comments are closed.