How Much Should You Tell Your Spouse About Sex During The Affair?
by: Katie Lersch: I sometimes receive emails from both wives and husbands who are absolutely stuck on this issue. It’s one of the most painful sticking points after infidelity, and it shows up in my inbox so often that I can almost anticipate the questions before I even open the message.
A wife will write something like: “I keep asking my husband to tell me every single sexual detail about the affair. I feel like I deserve the truth. This affected my marriage, my health, and my life. How am I supposed to trust him again if he won’t be completely honest?”
And then, sometimes, I’ll hear from a husband who says:
“My wife wants to know everything – down to positions, locations, and specifics. I want to be honest, but I’m terrified that these details will only hurt her more. I feel like I’m going to make things worse no matter what I do.”
Most people can read these two perspectives and immediately understand that both spouses have valid points. The faithful spouse wants transparency, safety, and honesty. The unfaithful spouse worries that giving explicit sexual details will only deepen the trauma. And, frankly, they’re not wrong.
So who’s right?
Often, the real answer lies somewhere in the middle, and I’ll explain why.
How Much Detail Do You Actually Need?: Speaking as someone who has lived through this and as someone who hears from couples daily on my blog, I believe the faithful spouse absolutely has the right to information that protects their health and safety and gives them a clear understanding of what they’re dealing with.
You deserve to know:
-
Whether your health was put at risk
-
Whether pregnancy is a possibility
-
How long the sexual relationship lasted
-
Whether the affair is completely over
These are not “gossip” details. These are necessary, grounding facts that help you make informed decisions about how (or if) you want to move forward.
But then there are the other details.
The ones you think might give you clarity or closure, but instead create vivid images that replay in your head at 3 a.m. and sabotage your healing.
Things like:
-
What lingerie she wore
-
Specific positions
-
How she acted in bed
-
Tiny visual details that take root in your mind and refuse to leave
I have been that faithful spouse, and I can tell you with complete honesty: once those images enter your mind, they can be impossible to banish. They can keep you stuck, angry, hurt, and unable to move forward, even when you desperately want to.
If You’re The Faithful Spouse And You Want “Every Detail”: I completely understand the impulse. After all, someone has upended your world. Wanting answers is a very human reaction.
But I often gently encourage spouses to reconsider asking for every detail.
You don’t need graphic visuals in your head to understand what happened.
You need clarity. Not trauma.
There’s a difference between understanding the scope of the affair and knowing which bra she wore on a particular Tuesday.
One brings grounding.
The other brings unnecessary pain.
If You’re The Unfaithful Spouse And You’re Being Pressured To Tell Everything: This is such a difficult situation. You want to be transparent. You want to rebuild trust. But you’re also – often rightly – afraid that certain details will retraumatize your spouse.
In these cases, I suggest telling your spouse something like:
“I want to be completely honest with you. I’m not trying to hide anything. But I’m worried that some of the graphic details will only hurt you and keep us from healing. I want to give you everything you need to feel informed, safe, and respected. But I also want to protect you from unnecessary pain. Can we take this slowly and focus first on the facts that truly matter to our recovery?”
Not every spouse will accept this immediately.
In fact, some may push harder.
But if you consistently show honesty, remorse, responsibility, and respect, the intensity of the demand often eases over time. When a betrayed spouse begins to believe that you truly love them, that you’re invested in repairing the marriage, and that the affair is completely in the past, the need for granular details tends to fade.
Because the more hopeful they feel about the future, the less they cling to the specifics of the past.
Healing Is Still Possible. Even If You Can’t See That Yet: There was a time I couldn’t imagine ever getting past my husband’s affair. I thought the marriage was dead. I thought I was too broken. I thought the images in my head would torture me forever.
But I was wrong.
Although I never would have believed it at the time, my marriage is stronger today than it was before the affair. It wasn’t magic. It wasn’t instant. It was slow, steady, emotional work. But it was worth it.
And here’s the surprising part:
My self-esteem is higher today than it ever was before.
I don’t wake up fearing that he will cheat again.
I don’t obsess over the details anymore because they no longer define me or my marriage.
If you want to read the very personal story of how I got here, you can do that on my blog: http://surviving-the-affair.com
Filed under: Uncategorized by admin
Comments Off on How Much Should You Tell Your Spouse About Sex During The Affair?
